Homemade Pizza Seasoning

I started making this pizza seasoning mix years ago when the kids were little and we had sports more nights than not, and things were too busy for anything but a frozen pizza pulled straight from the freezer to the oven. The pizza was never going to taste homemade, but a spoonful of this dressed it up enough to get by. These days I make my own dough and sauce far more often than not, but I still reach for this same jar every time pizza is on the menu.

Why Bother Making Your Own?

Fair question, because you can buy a shaker of “pizza seasoning” at any grocery store. Here’s why I don’t anymore.

When you mix your own, you know exactly what’s in the jar — herbs, a little salt, a little heat, and nothing else. No anti-caking agents, no mystery “spices,” no more salt than you decided to put there. You also get to use herbs that haven’t been sitting in a warehouse. If you grow oregano or thyme and dry them yourself, this blend is a great way to use it.

But honestly, the biggest reason is flavor. This mix has ruined store-bought Italian seasoning for me. Italian seasoning tastes flat by comparison, this blend has depth from the onion flakes, warmth from the red pepper, and a piney backbone from the rosemary and thyme that makes everything it touches taste like it came out of a real pizzeria oven.

And it only takes five minutes to make. Maybe less.

What Each Ingredient Is Doing in This Mix

None of these herbs is an accident, and once you know what each one contributes, you can adjust the blend with confidence.

Oregano is the anchor — it’s the flavor most of us mean when we say something “tastes like pizza.” It carries the whole blend, which is why it gets the largest measure.

Basil softens and sweetens. Where oregano is sharp, basil is round. Together they’re the classic Italian pairing.

Rosemary is the sleeper ingredient. Just a teaspoon adds a piney, almost savory depth that store blends never have. This is the one people can’t identify but always notice.

Onion flakes do the heavy lifting for savoriness. A tablespoon and a half sounds like a lot, but once ground down, they melt into sauces and doughs and give the blend real body instead of just “herbiness.”

Thyme is quiet but earthy — a quarter teaspoon is enough to tie the rosemary to the rest of the blend.

Coarse sea salt wakes everything up. It’s a modest amount on purpose, so you stay in control of the salt in your finished dish.

Crushed red pepper flakes bring gentle warmth, not real heat, at this quantity. It’s the low hum in the background that makes the blend taste finished.

Garlic powder — just a whisper. Enough to round things out without shouting over the herbs.

Making the Blend Your Own

This recipe is a starting point, not a rulebook. A few adjustments I’ve made or readers have written to me about:

• Like it hot? Double the red pepper flakes, or add a pinch of cayenne if your family likes a pizza with some attitude.
• Watching salt? Leave it out entirely. The blend works beautifully salt-free, and you can season the finished dish to taste.
• Garlic lovers can bump the garlic powder up to a full teaspoon — it holds its own.
• Add fennel seed (about 1/2 teaspoon, lightly crushed) if you want that sausage-shop, old-school pizzeria flavor. This one’s wonderful in sauce.
• A tablespoon of grated Parmesan mixed in right before using makes a fantastic finishing sprinkle for garlic bread — just don’t store it in the jar, since cheese shortens the shelf life.

If you dry your own herbs from the garden, use them here. Home-dried oregano, in particular, is so much more potent than store-bought that you may want to start with a little less and taste as you go.

How I Actually Use It (Hint: It’s Not Just for Pizza)

I started by sprinkling this on my pizza crusts before baking, and it snowballed from there. This jar gets more use than almost anything else on my spice shelf:

1. Sprinkled on pizza crust before the toppings go on — the original use, still the best.
2. Stirred into pizza sauce — a teaspoon transforms a can of plain crushed tomatoes.
3. Kneaded right into bread dough — I add about a teaspoon to the ingredients in my bread maker so the flavor bakes into the loaf itself. Readers have written to tell me their families devoured herbed loaves made this way.
4. In the ricotta filling for stuffed shells — a teaspoon, and it’s the thing everyone asks about.
5. In baked ziti — always. No exceptions in this house.
6. On homemade breadsticks and focaccia — brushed with a little olive oil first so it sticks.
7. On roasted potatoes — toss with olive oil, roast, and finish with a sprinkle of Parmesan. A reader suggestion I’ve fully adopted; it gives the potatoes a wonderful Italian flavor.
8. In mashed potatoes — another reader idea that turned out to be inspired.
9. In salad dressing — a half teaspoon shaken with olive oil and red wine vinegar makes an instant Italian vinaigrette.
10. On garlic bread — mixed into softened butter with a little Parmesan.
11. Over buttered popcorn, sautéed vegetables, scrambled eggs, or grilled chicken — anywhere you’d reach for Italian seasoning, reach for this instead.

Once it’s on the shelf, you’ll find your own uses. That’s rather the point.

Storage & Shelf Life

Homemade pizza seasoning stores very well in an airtight container. My favorite setup is a mason jar with a shaker lid — I can flip the top open and measure out exactly what I need without fishing for a spoon, and it looks right at home on the shelf.

Kept sealed in a cool, dry spot away from the stove’s heat and steam, the blend stays at its best for about 6 months. It won’t spoil after that — dried herbs are shelf-stable for a year or more — but the flavor slowly fades. The test is simple: open the jar and take a sniff. If it smells like a pizzeria, you’re fine. If it smells like faint, dusty hay, it’s time to mix a new batch.

Two small habits that extend the life of the blend: don’t shake it directly over a steaming pot (the moisture gets in and clumps the herbs), and don’t store it right above the stove where heat cooks the flavor away.

Homemade vs. Store-Bought: Is There Really a Difference?

Yes — and it’s not subtle. Here’s the honest comparison:

• Freshness. Dried herbs lose potency from the day they’re processed. A store-bought blend may have been packaged a year before it reached your cart. Yours was mixed this afternoon.
• Salt and fillers. Many commercial blends lean heavily on salt because it’s cheap, and some include anti-caking agents. In this recipe, salt is a supporting player, and you can dial it down to zero.
• Cost. If you’re already stocking basic dried herbs, a batch of this costs pennies. A specialty “pizza seasoning” shaker runs several dollars for a blend that’s mostly oregano and salt anyway.
• Control. This is the real difference. Spicier, saltier, more garlic, no garlic — the blend answers to you.

The only thing store-bought has going for it is that you don’t have to measure eight things. Given that the measuring takes five minutes and the jar lasts months, I’ll take the five minutes.

A Few Things I’ve Learned Along the Way

• The spice grinder step matters more than it seems. A few pulses breaks the rosemary needles and onion flakes down so the blend distributes evenly — and the smaller pieces disappear into melted cheese instead of sitting on top. A mortar and pestle works too, and smells wonderful while you do it.
• A little goes a long way. More than one reader has learned this the enthusiastic way. Start with a light sprinkle or a level teaspoon; you can always add more.
• Bake it in, don’t just sprinkle it on. Adding the seasoning to dough or sauce builds flavor from the inside out. On top and inside is the move for maximum effect.
• Check your oregano before you start. The blend is only as good as its oldest herb. If your oregano has been open since two kitchens ago, buy fresh — it’s the backbone of the whole mix.
• Make it a gift. A batch in a small mason jar with a handwritten label is a lovely, useful Christmas or hostess gift. One reader made a double batch just for gifting, and I’ve done the same ever since.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use this in place of Italian seasoning? Yes — and I’d argue you should. I use it as a straight one-for-one swap in any recipe that calls for Italian seasoning, and the results are noticeably better. The onion, garlic, and red pepper give it a depth Italian seasoning simply doesn’t have.

What kind of red pepper flakes should I buy? The crushed red pepper flakes in the spice aisle, the same kind that comes in shakers at pizza shops. McCormick is the most common brand, but any will do.

Is this blend spicy? Not at the written quantity — it’s warmth, not heat. If you’re cooking for anyone who’s very heat-sensitive, you can halve the red pepper flakes or leave them out.

Can I make it salt-free? Absolutely. Just omit the sea salt; everything else stays the same. This is one of the best reasons to make your own.

Do I have to grind it? No — you can simply stir everything together and it will still taste wonderful. Grinding just gives you a more even blend and a finer texture that melts into cheese and sauce better.

How much should I use on a pizza? A light sprinkle over the sauce or crust — roughly 1/2 to 1 teaspoon for a standard pizza. Remember, a little goes a long way.

Can I use fresh herbs instead of dried? Not for a shelf-stable blend, fresh herbs will mold in the jar. If you have fresh herbs from the garden, either dry them first or chop them and add them directly to your pizza the day you bake.

---

Do you have a use for this blend I haven’t discovered yet? Tell me in the comments, half of my favorite ways to use it came from readers.

• 

  Homemade Seasonings and Mixes | Recipes

  Homemade Shake and Bake

  ByJennifer Morrisey November 30, 2015January 19, 2026

  Sharing is caring! 2431 shares Share Tweet Pin   My mother denies this now, but growing shake and bake pork chops were always on the weekly menu rotation. And, in my mother’s defense why not? Shake & Bake was, and still is all about convenience. Drop a few pieces of meat in a bag with…

• 

  Homemade Seasonings and Mixes | Recipes

  Homemade Rice Seasoning Mix

  ByJennifer Morrisey November 18, 2015January 19, 2026

  It has been a while since I have shared a recipe for a homemade mix.  I really feel like it is time to get back into stocking my pantry with homemade mixes and seasonings, most of my mixes have been depleted and I have been mixing on the fly. Rice can be kind of boring, Homemade…

• 

  Homemade Seasonings and Mixes | Recipes

  Chicken Seasoning Blend

  ByJennifer Morrisey April 8, 2015January 19, 2026

  Today I am sharing another homemade mix recipe, that I absolutely love. Chicken Seasoning Blend is a savory dry rub that really adds a unique delicious flavor to chicken. Chicken seasoning blend is a quick and easy way to add flavor to roasted, grilled and baked chicken. This dry rub mix makes a big enough batch to…

• 

  Dips, Dressings & Sauces | Homemade Seasonings and Mixes | Recipes

  Baker’s Cinnamon Filling Recipe

  ByJennifer Morrisey March 23, 2015January 19, 2026

  Oh my gosh, this cinnamon roll filling is it, guys! I love cinnamon rolls, but I could never figure out how to get the consistency of the filling right. some fillings turned out too dry and baked right into the dough, and some too thin and would run out of the roll to the bottom of…

• 

  Homemade Seasonings and Mixes | Recipes

  Homemade Ranch Dressing Mix

  ByJennifer Morrisey February 26, 2015January 19, 2026

  I have been playing around more and more with homemade substitutions for packaged convenience foods, it is something I have actually enjoyed doing and it is really helpful when it comes to keeping the grocery budget under control. Homemade Ranch Dressing Mix is the latest homemade mix to hit my pantry, it took me a while to…

• 

  Desserts and Sweets | Homemade Seasonings and Mixes | Recipes

  Homemade Brownie Mix

  ByJennifer Morrisey January 28, 2015January 19, 2026

   Keep Homemade Brownie Mix on hand to mix up whenever a chocolate craving strikes. It has all the convenience of a boxed mix made with a made from scratch taste. Last week my laptop died. It was a miserable old thing that held on much longer than it should have. The past month has been…